About Michael Calico Jewelers


Michael Calico Jewelers is dedicated to providing fine jewelry that celebrates creativity, life, and love. We focus our experience and resources to offer distinctive jewelry, quality services, professional help, and real value.  We care deeply about our customers’ satisfaction.


Our family-owned business in Blue Ash, Ohio, has a valued reputation for customer service and selection of diamonds, engagement rings, wedding bands, custom jewelry, and consignment sales. We surpass many other Blue Ash jewelers with our years of expertise and customer delight. Our team of highly skilled craftsmen can repair and design your jewelry.

Whether helping you choose the perfect gemstone or restoring a treasured family heirloom, our expertise and experience work together to ensure you get exactly what you want. We offer distinctive styles and create beautiful custom designs. We’re proud to serve thousands of families in the Cincinnati area, including Blue Ash, Kenwood, and Montgomery communities.



Our selection of diamonds includes everything from engagement rings and settings to delicate necklaces and earrings. You can find the size, clarity, and style of your choice through in-store options, or we can order from one of our trusted partners to deliver exactly what you are looking for in diamond jewelry. 


Engagement Rings and Wedding Bands

Your engagement ring and wedding bands are some of the most emotional and meaningful purchases of your lifetime. We celebrate your journey with you by offering an extensive collection of gorgeous engagement rings that you will be proud to display for a lifetime. We offer wedding bands for brides and grooms so you can have the perfect rings for your marriage. 



Great financing options are yours when approved by Kemba Credit Union. Up to 24 months no interest options to qualified buyers.  Quick credit decisions.

Gold Buying and Estate Jewelry Sales

At Michael Calico Jewelers, we buy gold, precious metals, and estate jewelry. Gold and other precious metals like silver and platinum always have value and easy liquidity. Now is the time to sell your jewelry that is no longer worn or is broken. We continually pay top dollar for large diamonds including old vintage cuts.


On-site jewelry repairs are expertly handled by our experienced goldsmith. Need it in a hurry? Ask about our RUSH service and you may have your repair same day.


Appraisals & Evaluation

Our in-house full time appraiser can help identify and appraise or evaluate your item(s). Insurance and estate appraisals are very frequently requested services as well as cash-out evaluations.


Consignment Sales 

Want to sell your jewelry? In addition to buying your precious metals on the spot we offer a consignment service to market your fine jewelry. Let us do the work and take the risks to convert your items into cash.